Why Similar Postures in a Form Mean Little

 

Many applications and usages in Chinese martial arts can be found in numerous different styles.  One of the reasons for common applications is that over the centuries, certain applications have been found to be so generally useful that most Chinese martial arts adopted those applications.  Remember that the Chinese martial arts evolved over thousands of years and the better techniques have been codified and saved.

 

One of the prominent features of the Chinese martial arts (and the other Asian martial arts that borrowed from the Chinese) is how the body mechanics are used.   The Chinese developed a system of whole-body strength, using the middle of the body as a pivot as it Opens and Closes, that optimized the use of strength, while using less muscular effort.  The system of strength and mechanics that is the hallmark of Chinese martial arts is often denoted by the Yin-Yang Symbol ☯, indicating the constant cycling of Open and Close.

 

The problem is that almost all techniques and applications can also be done using what could be called "normal, muscular strength".   If we look at the well-known joint-lock below (called "xiao tran" in Chinese; "nikyo" in Aikido, etc.) we can visualize this particular bending of a joint as being done either with arm strength or with the elastic-contractile tissues of the whole body, as motivated through the dantian/tanden.   Those two radically different ways of moving the body will look very similar to a casual observer, but they are very different.

 

My point is that while we sometimes hear people explain that some martial arts are related because they contain a certain number of the same techniques, that really means little.  One art may be using "normal, muscular strength" while the other art may be using the qi and jin that are the famous hallmarks of ancient Chinese martial arts.  Regardless of having the same posture and appearance of many techniques, the arts may be totally unrelated other than the fact that they also utilize some of the old, provenly effective techniques that were developed through the ages.

 



 

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

 Jin a la Aunkai Discussion   Bear in mind that the 6H forum is more investigatory about jin, qi, dantian, reverse breathings, etc., and is less interested in actual martial usage.  Aunkai is a focused martial pursuit, so there is no parallel in goals, although Rob John and some of the other Aunkai demigods do pursue a level of "how to explain this" and "how does this work".  Anyway, to cut to the chase, this is a brief discussion about jin, at least from a 6H perspective.  I'll let some of the Aunkai guys explain the subtleties and nuances that they posit we are missing (in good humor, of course).  😉   Jin is defined as "the physical manifestation of qi" and you can find that definition in a number of texts from different Chinese martial arts.  What that statement means is that a jin force-path is arranged by the mind arranging or "willing" how the subconscious-controlled involuntary-muscle/fascia systems act.  Often, during a day,
Read more
Qi, Jin, Structure, Direction of Forces by Mike Sigman  IMO the best way to start learning jin is to hold something in your arms and practice adjusting your structure so that the weight of what you're holding goes straight through your bones/structure and rests on the ground.   The reason primitive porters can carry so much load on their heads or shoulders is because they have learned to allow the weight to go through their bones and rest on the ground:   if the weight is allowed to rest on the ground, that's less of a burden that your muscles have to carry.   This is Basic jin 101. When you are mentally "adjusting" your structure to let a weight rest at the bottom of your feet, you are using "intent" or "yi".   Mentally adjusting your structure inside involves the subconscious mind following your imagined process of letting the weight rest at the bottom of your and directing a myriad of involuntary-muscles connected to fascia, muscle
Read more

The Silly Magic of Asian Martial Arts versus Reality

Image
The Silly Magic of Asian Martial Arts versus Reality Mike Sigman: March 2020 I was reading some remarks by a "Tai Chi" enthusiast and I spotted right away that there was something not right with his mentation … his words were full of nonsense prattle and attempted to portray some knowledge of Hidden Secrets that he was privy to.   The more I thought about it, the more I thought "this guy is really doing nothing different than a lot of established "Tai Chi Teachers". I've watched a couple of qigong videos in the last week or so and I decided it was a waste of time for people to take these online videos seriously.   I watched one video by an absolute master/expert that I know personally, and the video was very clear in how the choreography went … however, I knew that this man would never discuss or explain the ramifications of the breathing, qi, jin, and involvement of the subconscious mind.    So basically, most people would simply learn a chor
Read more